The Vital Question: Tracing the Argument

Intro This book is structured rather like a review of the literature. When discussing a question, Nick Lane first walks through the existing theories, so part of the pleasure of reading it is following his thinking as he explains a theory and then rules it out. The downside is that it is not always an easy read, and I sometimes lose track of the main argument. Here, then, is a chronological outline of the theory he puts forward.

The Theological Origins of Modernity: Tracing the Argument

Modernity Much of the confusion surrounding modernity comes from its temporal name: literally, it means being “new.” More specifically, this newness means inaugurating something unprecedented in the flow of time, a novel way of existing. One might even say that its ultimate ambition is not merely a form of being, but a form of becoming. The dividing line between the ancient and the modern lies in their views of one thing: universals. In the ancient world, realism was the prevailing orthodoxy, holding universals to be ultimate reality.

Reflections on Gödel, Escher, Bach

Intro Let me quote a popular Douban review from more than a decade ago. Reducing the book to this one line does mythologize it a little too much, but it still conveys something of its impact: There are only two kinds of people in the world: those who have read this book, and those who have not. To my mind, there are two main reasons readers find it so special: Its form is extraordinarily elegant and entertaining.